Usuario discusión:Whaledad

Redirige a:

• q:nl:Overleg gebruiker:Whaledad

The Pic Signed With JDL

There is no proof this text was written by the JDL, or the JDL even had just something to dit with it. If it is not the work of the JDL it has nothing to do at the article of JDL. Everyone can write JDL on a wall with some racist texts above it. Probably the work of opponents of JDL. If you add it to the article like you want to do, the reader will see it as the work of the JDL. Which it most likely is not; i.e. there is no proof it is.

I can write some terrible racist stuff about black people on the wall and then sign it with "George W. Bush", make a pic of it and add it to the article about George W. Bush. That would, of course, not be accepted. Here happens the same. There is no proof at all that the JDL wrote this racist text, so one cannot link it to the JDL, neither in a quasi 'subtile' way. SwedishSven (talk) 16:15, 22 January 2011 (UTC)

• The picture is signed JDL and that's what the caption says. You have been removing this picture on all Wikis around the world under the user names SwedischSven and Istochleukzonnaam. In Sweden you have been blocked for this for three days. Please stop your vandalism and sockpuppetery. Whaledad (discusión) 17:41 22 ene 2011 (UTC)
  • You are not responding to my arguments. SwedishSven (discusión) 18:00 22 ene 2011 (UTC)
    • That's because your statement above isn't really an argument... even though it is argumentative. The statement was signed JDL. The picture was placed with a text that it was signed JDL. It didn't say it was placed by JDL. On the other hand it is highly unlikely that others (Arabs?) would paint statements of this sort. And you haven't presented any arguments that make this even in the slightest sense likely. Has any Arab ever been caught writing statements in name of JDL? Has any Arab ever been caught killing another Arab trying to make it look like it was done by JDL?
    • Note that this user has now been blocked on one or more of his sock puppet accounts for these vandalistic edits in SV, Simple, EN, Meta and NL. Whaledad (discusión) 15:51 23 ene 2011 (UTC)