Usuario discusión:Tehonk

Sorin Cerin

Hola @Tehonk, no entiendo el motivo de la tu plantilla de borrado, ya que el artículo ya ha sido revisado. Fuera de ello, no veo que en la wikipedia en español exista "cross-wiki spam that was deleted previously" como motivo de borrado. Si el artículo -suponiendo que entiendo el texto- fue borrado en otra Wikipedia, no puedes emplearlo como argumento para plantillear el artículo actual. Te agradecería que me aclararas tu forma de actuar y quitaras la plantilla. Espero tu respuesta. Le mando el hilo a @Bineart. Gracias y un saludo. Rafstr (discusión) 06:12 14 sep 2023 (UTC)

Hi @Rafstr the logs of the page shows it was deleted from here previously as cross-wiki spam. I see that it's being spammed to several wikis with bad machine translations from time to time. Tehonk (discusión) 06:52 14 sep 2023 (UTC)

Hi Tehonk, sorry, but I don't understand how you can put a deletion template based on logs and not on the current content of the article. The page exists on both French and Spanish Wikipedia and its content is good. Rafstr (discusión) 07:04 14 sep 2023 (UTC)

Hi Tehonk @Tehonk I see that you use the log of the deletion of this article from en.wikipedia from 2006. How can you do such a thing when the current article translated from French does not contain even a book that was printed in 2006 or before this year. All the books appearing in the current Sorin Cerin article were published starting in 2007. The first literary critics wrote about Sorin Cerin's work only starting in 2009. All the reviews appearing in the current article were published after 2009. While you use the journal deletion of this article from 2006 which is this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Sorin_Cerin

I can't understand how you consider a deletion log from 2006, when the current Sorin Cerin article has nothing appeared in it until 2006. The entire article has completely new content compared to the Sorin Cerin article from 2006, new content appeared starting with the year 2007 in the chapter of publications and starting with the year 2009 in the chapter of reviews. We are talking about a completely different article. As for translations, I am a professor at a university where I teach French and Spanish. I know what I wrote in the article. The article Sorin Cerin has gone through all the stages of admissibility on the French language wikipedia. He was voted for several months until he became admitted. I don't understand how you can ask for the deletion of an article on the grounds of a deletion journal from 2006, when that article has nothing in its content from that year or from the previous years. Bineart (discusión) 07:40 14 sep 2023 (UTC)